The Character And Comfort Of The Shepherd Mayfair

There is a corner of Mayfair that has always kept its historic character, and it was here that we spent two of the most comfortable nights we can remember. Shepherd Market, with its narrow lanes, old pubs and pavement tables, felt a world away from the grand hotels of Park Lane just a few streets over. The Shepherd Mayfair, our home for two days, has made its home on the land where The Cottage, thought to be Mayfair’s oldest house, stood from 1618 until it was destroyed in the Blitz. We arrived through a discreet arcade walkway and knew straight away that this was a place we would find very hard to leave.

We had the pleasure of staying in the Shepherd Suite, which felt less like a hotel room and more like a bedroom in a well-loved townhouse. Glossy lacquered wood furnishings were set against soft, muted tones, with flashes of blue, curved upholstery and red velvet curtains. Every piece rewarded a closer look. The desk doubled as a dressing table, a console table had a wooden chessboard set into its top, and a brass banker’s lamp sat on the desk – a charming throwback to the era of late-night letter writing. The marble bathroom was a highlight in its own right, with an enormous walk-in shower and Floris toiletries in bottles made just for the hotel. Then there were the dressing gowns. They were so thick and plush that they were easily some of the comfiest hotel robes we have ever worn, and quite honestly, they made us never want to leave the room. Beyond the suite, designer Timothy Shepherd of Shepherd& had hidden small stories throughout the building, from Jack English photographs along the corridors to braille and Morse code details that nodded to the area’s wartime intelligence past. None of it was spelled out for us, and we loved discovering it at our own pace.

We continued our stay with dinner at Fayre, the hotel’s main restaurant, which takes its name and its spirit from the old May Fair, a rowdy fifteen-day festival that once filled the area every spring. Dark timber panelling, banquette seating and deep mulberry tones made the room feel theatrical yet intimate. Artist Adam Ellis had covered the walls with scenes of livestock markets, performers and games of chance, a reminder of Mayfair’s humble beginnings, long before it became a byword for luxury. Pride of place went to a portrait of Mary Davies, the heiress whose marriage into the Grosvenor family brought this land into their hands and laid the foundations for the Mayfair we know today.

And then, of course, there was the food. Fayre’s menu was seasonal British cooking with European touches. On our first night, we began with braised beef short rib croquettes, a crispy duck confit salad and slow-cooked confit pork belly, before moving on to an exquisite roast halibut and a beautifully cooked ribeye. For dessert, we shared a blueberry cheesecake and an apple and plum crumble with vanilla custard. The crumble was a generous tribute to traditional home-made English cooking and, dare we say, quite possibly one of the best we have ever eaten.

We enjoyed it so much that we went back the following evening. The short rib croquettes made a welcome second appearance, this time alongside a twice-baked cheddar soufflé, followed by a rich lamb ragu and a proper plate of haddock and chips. Naturally, we couldn’t leave without another apple and plum crumble. The food quality was second to none, and every dish was cooked with real care. Fayre was the kind of dining experience we would happily return to even without a room upstairs.

Then came the gin trolley, created exclusively for the hotel by Suffolk distillery Moatwood, known for its wild-foraged botanicals. The trolley itself was made from a fallen tree in Kensington Palace Gardens and hand-finished by a craftsman in Hackney. As it moved through the hotel, it carried a little piece of London’s history with it. It was theatre, craftsmanship and very good gin in one elegant package.

Breakfast, also served in Fayre, was every bit as good as dinner. It was unhurried, generous and beautifully done, the kind of breakfast that made a slow start to the day feel well earned. Back in our suite, we found a thoughtful gift of Miamo skincare. Miamo is an Italian clinical brand founded by two pharmacists, and its products were also stocked in the in-room minibars, with full skincare routines available to order through in-room dining.

What stayed with us most, though, was the people. The staff were warm, knew the hotel inside out and were refreshingly free of stiffness. Every request we made was handled with ease, and nothing ever felt like too much trouble.

The Shepherd Mayfair is not trying to be the biggest or loudest hotel in the area. From the plush robes to second helpings of crumble, our whole stay was centred around comfort and feeling at home. It is a hotel that knows its neighbourhood, honours its history and is run by people who clearly care. Mayfair has plenty of places to stay, but few are this easy to settle into.

Photography courtesy of The Shepherd.

theshepherdmayfair.com

Shopping cart0
There are no products in the cart!
Continue shopping
0